
The name, which translates to “Johnny Hall,” refers to a colloquial term for an unruly, rock throwing mob. It’s supposed to describe the chaotic look of chopped nuts and sugar chunks on top. It’s also ironic in a way, because this cookie is pure, clean deliciousness built on a platform of butter, cinnamon, and assorted extras. It may look chaotic, but it isn’t.
We struggled a bit over our rule against bar cookies, but that purity, the thin texture, the absence of anything gooey, and the cultural significance all combine to earn Jan Hagels a pass. That’s our story and we’re sticking to it!
That was pretty much the only hurdle. The recipe itself is super easy. Combine the dough ingredients, and spread into a rectangle on sheet of parchment. Bake to get here:


Slice the baked mega-cookie into squares, diamonds, or any other shape you prefer.

Array prettily, and then let the hungry hordes know there’s goodies to be had.

NOTE: The recipe calls for “pearl sugar.” This is a decorative sugar common along the shores of the North Sea and the Baltic Sea, but hard to find in the U.S. Imagine small nonpareils that maintain their shape in the oven but aren’t hard, and crush instantly beneath your teeth. You can make a reasonable substitute from a slurry of 1 cup of white sugar and 3-4 tbsp. of water, putting this in a pot over very low heat, and then continually stirring with a wooden spoon until it clumps into ⅛” pieces that harden as they cool. But honestly, it’s there to look pretty more than it’s there to taste. Substitute as desired if you don’t have that particular ingredient.
ADDED NOTE: The Belgians have a caramelized version of pearl sugar that might be even more appropriate. We used the Scandinavian white version because it’s what we had on hand.
AND A THIRD NOTE WHILE WE’RE AT IT: Neither the almonds nor the pearl sugar add a whole lot by way of either taste or texture. Experiment at will!
[Sigh. This whole “one more thing…” thing gets exhausting after a while. Give it a rest dude].
CONCLUSION
This is one of those cookies that every human being will like. Buttery, cinnamony goodness with some sliced almonds and other pretty decorations. They will positively vanish from your house, just as they did from ours. Personally, I blame the gremlins. Kate , our photographer, has different ideas, but they are too outrageous to mention. One thing we both agree on is this: it was definitely not human hands wandering by to unconsciously grab the proverbial ‘just one more.’
NOTE FROM KATE: I had trouble photographing this cookie. First, pieces kept disappearing as people walked past it (I had to wait for the light to be just right, you see.) Everyone wanted a piece, even one of our fireplace foxes. But house spirits get their share as well! This cookie won’t last long in your home either.




Enjoy!

